View RSS Feed

melev

Day 365 – One year old today

Rate this Entry
Today, my reef turns one year old, but I can’t really feel the reason to celebrate. If anything, I’ve been really frustrated that my reef isn’t humming along nicely and showcasing beautiful corals that have been growing in over the past twelve months. At nine months, it was looking great and was vivid with color, now it feels almost like I’m starting over.



Granted, I’ve been very busy over the past few months speaking to clubs across the nation and focusing on MACNA 2012. My tank sitter has done his best to watch the tank closely and make adjustments as necessary to keep things thriving during each of my absenses. Be that as it may, when it comes to keeping a reef tank happy, the only person that truly knows what to do is its owner.

What happened, you ask? A series of things, as well as a combination of these. The biggest factor was the problem I was having with my calcium reactor. For nearly two months, it was sucking in too much air from somewhere, and it looked like a bubbly tornado instead of being clear liquid. I took it apart looking for the problem, set it up anew and within a couple of days, the cyclone returned. I’ve had this calcium reactor since 2004, and am acutely knowledgeable about how it operates, but I couldn’t find the source of the problem. Due to it being less than consistent, I was dosing baked Baking Soda as needed to supplement alkalinity to the tank. The numbers rose and fell on a weekly basis. I called Lifereef for advice, and discussed ordering all the soft parts to give it a tune up. The alkalinity coming out of the calcium reactor should be 19 dKH or higher, but mine was barely putting out 8 (that was probably the same as the water in the system, now that I think about it).

Another problem was that the Aquacontroller 3 wasn’t communicating properly with the heaters in the sump. The x-10 modules that have always worked became sporadic, at best. The signal to turn the heaters on wasn’t always received. Temperatures bounced around a little, but it was never a huge fluctuation. I installed new probes on the controller, and during the calibration process accidentally entered the ORP calibration menu. When I tried to cancel out, the controller locked in a bad measurement and reported that the brand new probe was bad. Checking Google, the advice was to re-initialize the AC3 to get this reset. What I didn’t realize was that all of my web-settings would be wiped as well. So now I had a flakey controller/x-10 situation that didn’t communicate well with the heaters and other equipment under the aquarium, and I couldn’t even check on the system remotely.

The AEFWs were consuming some of my prettier SPS, and I wasn’t around to blow them off and keep them off. It was a losing battle. The tank sitter tried to turkey baste some corals, but the flatworms were winning.



I’ve been using biopellets since the tank was set up, with nitrates and phosphates measuring 0 all year. The past five months, I ran a liter of Coralvue's Biospheres and the pellets were diminishing in volume (as they should). However, the pellets were all but gone – maybe 1” worth remained in the reactor. Nitrates were still 0, but phosphates had climbed to somewhere between .25 and .5ppm. With my test kit, the solution should be clear, but this had a blue tint to it. One thing I really have to do this year is create a test kit station where I can have a nice white background and 6500K lighting to see the colors clearly. My house has colored walls in every direction and the tank lighting makes it tough to determine certain shades of color. Even going outside, my lawn is in hibernation mode (yellow) and the bushes are green, and the sky changes from cloudy to blue - but I digress. The point is, PO4 was up.

Water changes were performed, but small patches of cyano bacteria have surfaced here and there. The mixing pump for my 265g poly tank broke, and I’m waiting for the replacement to show up. For now, I mix up 41g of water at a time, as that matches one bag of Sybon reef salt. I need to get the big saltwater reservoir running again, both for regained space and consistent water changes.

As I looked at my dying corals, SPS primarily, I grew more and more upset. No-one is immune to things going wrong, but the honest truth is that people turn to me for advice... and I have this sad looking calling card that doesn’t reflect what I’m capable of. It’s times like this that I really miss my beautiful 280g reef!

Rebirth
The best way for me to get over something is to start fixing it. Remove everything that bothers me, repair what is broken, correct what is out of range and move forward. Fortunately, my amazing tank sitter decided to take matters into his own hands and took apart the calcium reactor and fixed it. Prior to my last trip, I asked him to replace the tubing running from the CO2 tank to the reactor, as the tubing felt somewhat brittle. He did that, plus more. He found the problems I was overlooking. With that done, alkalinity has stabilized at last.

With the elevated phosphate reading, I dosed Blue Life’s Phosphate Control. I absolutely love this product because it works overnight. I’ve been dosing Lanthanum chloride for about 6 or 7 years, whenever the tank needed it. This was the first time I needed to do so in the 400g, but I didn’t expect any reason for it not to work out. I didn’t even count the drops this time, as I was talking on the phone with someone as I dosed the product between the baffles of my sump for about two minutes. The water turned cloudy as it converted the phosphate to a solid (Phosphate Control is a flocculant), but overnight the water cleared up while the skimmer gobbled up the residue. PO4 measured 0 the next day.



The carbon was old and the water was a little murky to the eye. Because of my foul mood, I put this off far too long. I pulled out the Nextreef reactor, dumped out the used carbon and cleaned it up, then filled it up with fresh carbon and put it back into service. I also called David at Nextreef and ordered some new sponges for it. Usually carbon is changed out every two weeks.

The next step was to cut out all the dead skeletons. Removing what used-to-be is often a challenge for hobbyists, because they regret the loss of the coral as well as the time it took to grow it to that size. Leaving it in the tank will only lead to nuisance algae taking hold and a constant reminder of some failure (on the part of the hobbyist or due to equipment malfunction). The best thing you can do is cut that stuff out and get it out of sight. It will quickly raise your morale. I have a small bucket that I filled up with former corals grown in from fraglets, and while my hands were wet, I also removed anything else that littered the sandbed.

Mid-January, I installed the Apex controller to replace my AC3. I purchased the controller with two PB-8s (power bars with 8 plugs) and one PB-4 (power bar with 4 plugs), the display module, a new pH probe, a 15’ extension USB cable, and an power supply for power outages (plugged into a UPS for email notifications). With the lack of functionality of the AC3, and my next trip out of town (for a full week!) looming, I wanted to get the Apex online. Busy working daily to complete my customers’ acrylic orders prior to my departure, I ended up having all of Thursday to install and configure the new controller on my reef. As a general rule – one that we should always live by – never make a big change to your tank prior to leaving town. This is why the Apex was sitting near the tank for weeks, but I kept having to leave town. My gut told me that my reef was in real trouble and probably wouldn’t survive another week on my limping AC3, plus I’d have no idea how the tank was doing because it no longer was communicating with the router and my iPhone 4.



The EB8 and EB4 sockets were very similar to the DC8 that I’ve been using, so it didn’t take long to get stuff plugged in. The Apex is different though: the brain gets power from one of the energy bars via a USB cable rather than a power plug. My trip out of town was very early the next morning, and I couldn’t leave the Apex gear and wiring all over the place like an obstacle course for an entire week and expect the tank sitter to step around it gingerly. I focused my time doing cable management as the hours passed, and I called in a friend for reinforcement. He’s set up many Apex systems and I just wanted to get the basics programmed and have it communicate via the web. I’d already downloaded the Apex App to my iPad and iPhone. I had an Ethernet cable running from the Apex to the router, and could log into the Apex from Internet Explorer and Safari. Strangely, it doesn’t work with Firefox, my main choice of browser. He stayed until about 1 a.m. trying to get the system stable. I flew out of town four hours later, dreading that something was overlooked or mistakenly programmed. Fortunately, all went well and the Apex has been nearly perfect in every way. More programming will be added to the brain to fine tune various features, but it’s doing what it should and reporting all kinds of useful data that I peruse daily. Tank temperature has been quite stable, with a less than 2 degree shift daily. I will doing a full write up on the Apex controller in the near future.





Still, the tank looked like it needed more TLC. I took a bowl-scraping spatula and ran it between the glass and the sandbed to get that nice clean look. Using a credit card, I scraped the area where the glass and substrate meet to remove that green algae growth. The black acrylic panel that hides the overflow was scraped clean. All the Vortechs* were soaked and cleaned. The return penductors were brushed to remove the fuzzies and above-water salt creep. The Eheim Chimney was cleaned up, as was the internal half of the Portal viewer. The sump was wiped down and the front panel of the refugium was scraped clean of algae growth.


*This is a MP60 Vortech magnet, one year after use. It looks like the day it was installed in the tank, in perfect shape.

While I was doing all this cleaning inside the tank, the middle metal halide shut off suddenly, not on schedule and not due to the tank’s temperature getting too high. I powered down the ballast and noticed something smelled burnt. I saw some black ash on the glass panel within the pendant, but the bulb appeared to be intact. I inspected the ballast and cord and looked for signs of disrepair. 15 minutes later, I turned it on again with the iPhone and watched sparks rain down inside the pendant! These were shooting out of the backside of the mogul socket. During the Superbowl, I was rewiring the pendant. Fortunately, I had an extra (brand new) mogul socket that was almost the exact same size, one that has been sitting on a shelf for probably 8 years. Never throw away anything – you never know when you’ll need it... provided you know where you stored it. The 400w pendant was fixed that same night.








I’m going to be doing a full product review of the AquaMaxx NP Reactor. This was just put online last Friday, filled with Warner Marine’s EcoBak NP pellets. The reactor was filled with 1 liter of media, and the Next Reef reactor containing the remaining Biospheres was taken out of the sump. I should have done this January 1st, but didn't have time until now.



The reef is looking somewhat empty to my eye. The fish are fat and happy, active and alert. Two dwarf angels are still in quarantine but will be going in soon. The LPS, gorgonians, anemones, Nepthea, zoanthids, fungia, acans and ricordea seem to be doing quite well, but the SPS took the brunt of it. The Montiporas look rough, and some were lost. Once chalice is gone, another one damaged, but others look completely fine. I’m down to one final clam.



Is there a silver lining? All the gear needed to support life successfully is installed, the tank holds water, and the ecosystem has done well before. There’s room for new corals. The $80 starfish is finally in the reef, and seems to like having more space to explore. Can this reef grow into something prettier than it is now? Yes. I just hate the lost time and effort, and the beautiful corals I had until recently.






A few macros of the survivors.


















While it is nearly impossible to put one's finger upon the exact issue that caused a tank to decline, I'd have to say the biggest one was Alkalinity. It affects SPS and clams, and those are the biggest losses. I still have a number of trips ahead of me this year, but hopefully getting things back on track will allow the reef tank to flourish once more. I'm going to look at dosing more additives to replenish what the biopellets may be stripping from the water, as that could be another area of concern.

Hopefully next year, I'll have something prettier to write up.

Submit "Day 365 – One year old today" to Digg Submit "Day 365 – One year old today" to del.icio.us Submit "Day 365 – One year old today" to StumbleUpon Submit "Day 365 – One year old today" to Google

Comments

  1. blakew's Avatar
    Nice and thorough update Mark. While I'm sorry for your losses and understand your frustration, it is reassuring for those of us still relatively new to the hobby to see (1) that even those of you who have lots of experience in the hobby still have problems from time to time and (2) how you go about correcting those issues in your own tanks.

    One thing of which I am sure, having found Melev's Reef and read about your earlier tanks, your 400 will be beautiful in time.

    Thanks for the years of hard work and sharing your experiences with all of us.

    For what it's worth, you still have some beautiful corals.
  2. brotherd's Avatar
    Love your honesty even when things do not go as planned.Thanks for a great update too.And ya,people all over the world look to you for advice and inspiration.My new 180 is modeled a bit around your current system and if I can come even close to achieving what you have done I will be thrilled!
  3. evoracer's Avatar
    Persistence. If there is one thing this hobby teaches (preaches), that's it. And while it likely doesn't help you to hear it, believe me the fact that someone with your knowledge and experience in the hobby can also run into problems reminds the rest of us that sometimes these things can happen. Even to the best of us. Keep persisting, the reef will undoubtedly be incredible one day soon.
  4. vrba's Avatar
    Marc, I am really sorry to hear about the decline that seemed to affect your SPS and clams the most. Have you considered if perhaps the Angel might be partially responsible? I recently had a similar experience with losing a decent amount of SPS. In my situation, first the SPS started losing color, then shortly after that they went downhill quick. Prior to the decline of my SPS, they were flourishing. I was seeing great growth and they were all coloring up nicely. I then decided it was time to put an Angel in my tank. I have read various reports that Angels can live happily with SPS but to expect less polyp extension. My experience was certainly not just less polyp extension. I removed the Angel and things are finally beginning to turn around for the few pieces that survived my Angel experiment. As much as I love Angels, it looks like I will only be able to have my Swallow Tail Angel if I also want to have SPS. Interestingly enough, I did not have any issues with LPS or zoas/palys with the Angel in the tank. SPS seemed to be his meal of choice.
  5. Hat39406's Avatar
    Nice update Marc! Your tank will be even more awesome next year. You have been a very busy person lately. And, it's sometimes hard enough to find time or just overcome our human procrastinating ways.

    I think I'll go now and do some Maintenance and cleaning on my tank!
  6. Jnarowe's Avatar
    Fun stuff.It is indeed a hobby that can frustrate the dedicated. Don't forget to test the tank for stray voltage.
  7. Paul B's Avatar
    I know what the problem is. You have too many test kits, dosers and reactors. I don't have any. My last test kit came in a wooden box and said "keep in a cool chariott"
    But your tank looks great to me.
    Good luck.
    Paul
  8. Midnight's Avatar
    LOL @ Paul B. Certainly the calcium reactor played its part, but I wonder if the new bio-pellets may not have been doing such a great job like the first ones were?
  9. adam's Avatar
    Another plus, the remaining SPS in your tank is hardy. I'm still loving your tank and wouldn't mind if nothing was added just grown out. Keep going next year this tank will be amazing.
  10. Blown76mav's Avatar
    Man I thought I was the only one who experienced stuff like this. I love your honesty even if things aren't going the way you want them. It gives me hope that I can turn my reef back around. Thanks
  11. twomonsters's Avatar
    Sorry to hear about your loss, my tank is finally coming back after a crash in Sept. X10 modules can get alittle crazy with all the interference from power strips, TV's, lights, etc. sometimes the signal doesn't get there. Theres a newer product called INSTEON works great from Home Automation.
  12. kitch40's Avatar
    Also sorry to hear about your bad luck with your tank Marc. I guess it comes with the territory but with all the different components, it must be hard to keep on top of everything.
    Thank you for all of your advice as now I have the RODI unit and auto top up working and my tank is looking better than ever probably because of the increased stability of the water parameters. Wishing you the best successes Marc.
  13. DRW94's Avatar
    Sorry to hear of your frustrations. Even the most seasoned hobbiest have their down days. Just keep being patient and consistent, and everything will turn around. I feel your pain, my tank looks worse now than it did a year ago. Sometimes you have to take a few steps back before you can take more steps forward. This hobby is like marriage, there will be ups and there will be downs. You have an amazing tank, so you must be doing something right! You just have to keep on keeping on.