Please help I am getting strange reading of electricity in my Tanks
by
, 02-13-2011 at 06:17 PM (1829 Views)
Ok so here is where i am literally.
So about a week ago i tested for electricity in my tank. I had and auto clamp tester with leads and a cheep analog tester. I was getting strange results and consulted RC and then Marc who reminded me of his article he did some time ago. http://www.reefaddicts.com/content.p...ay-Electricity Using his article as my guide i set out to test again and decided to get a tester similar to the one he used to help eliminate human error.
So here are my strange results. I hope someone can make sense of them.
1. I do not get a shock from any of my tanks when i work on them. When working on 108gal sump i am usually bare foot on cement floor.
2. Did feel a sting a few times when working in the sump of the 108gal where i had a small cut. Not sure if this was the salt stinging or electricity.
3. 108gal readings
Nothing pluged in 7.5-8.4 volts
Skimmer 18.8v
return pump 4.6 ( because it is less then when i had nothing plugged in)
Heater in middle sump chamber 31.6v
Heater in return section 25.1v
Heater tank 17.5v
Aqua lifter pump 9.5v
lights glo t5 ho suspended not touching tank maybe .5v each x3
Power head 1 18.9
Power head 2 18.7-19.1v
With everything plugged in i get 18.2v
Test was done with red lead in sump and black in ground in the outlet.
I have 2 30gal fresh water tanks that have AC 70 and heaters. Here are there results
1. Nothing plugged in i get about 6v
2. Aqua clear 16volts
3. Heater and AC i get about 30v
SW 12gal nano
1. Nothing i get 2.1v
2. heater reads 11.5v
3. Pump reads 11.8
4. Both on i get 13v
So i am under the impression that i do not have a problem but there is something strange going on. When i had first looked on RC this is the thread i found http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/sh....php?t=1953487 I am Mustang in there and if you skip down near the bottom you will find a theory of induction. This is what i was leaning towards when i contacted Marc but then after reading his article i seconded guessed my self as he seemed to make practical sense. Thus leading to my now confused state. Any help or theories as to what is going on would be appreciated as i think Marc has it right but for some reason i can not duplicate his results. Thanks all
FYI i had to go out before i finished this post and decided to stop by my LFS and after testing 2 SW tanks and 3 FW tanks i found similar results as to what i am findings at home.
Here is a pic of my digital testers on my 108gal with everything on.